As an adult I’ve always had a conflicted relationship with gifts. Interestingly I enjoy giving rather than receiving but not because I dislike getting attention…it’s really more of that I get a lot of presents that I have no idea what to do with. That may make me sound unappreciative but that’s not it – I am honored that I have friends and family who want to show me their affection. But I also really dislike getting bric-brac or tchotchkes because I think that there has to be some better purpose for $10-20.
Here is my husband’s post on Give a Crap. Don’t Give Crap. Here’s How. I second the sentiment and I’ve got some additional ideas, some of which I’ve been trying to practice over the years:
- For a number of years, my mother has given an animal in our name to the Heifer Project and she gives us a small ornament or toy of the animal to put out at Christmas…we’ve got a menagerie at this point and it really makes me feel good. My husband and I took this a step further when we got married and registered at Heifer Project and Changing the Present for our wedding. We felt that changing the lives of people in real need was a much better way to celebrate our happiness than having another vase (we are older so that played a big part in our decision – we have most of the household items we need already). Somewhere there is a herd of llamas helping families in need along with Koester the Pig (named in honor of my grandmother) and some geese, rabbits, and other assorted animals.
- Another thing that I like to do if I feel the need to give a gift is to give something that is consumable. My step-mother’s brother, to honor the memory of her father who loved smoked turkey, always sent one for the holiday. It was a gift that was both very yummy but also had a powerful emotional tie. My father-in-law eats smoked salmon religiously every morning. For a man who is extremely hard to buy for, a smoked salmon of the month club was perfect. It gives him something he will definitely use and something special that he would not buy for himself. A good friend of mine and I have often exchanged tickets to events that we attend together and results in a great memory.
This year, although gas and oil prices have come down, I am considering giving the gift of warmth. Citizens Energy here in Massachusetts is a good option as is Salvation Army’s Coats for Kids program. Other things that I am considering are local Food Banks, Dress for Success, and Big Brothers Big Sisters.
I am by no means against gifts but often we seem to get gifts because we feel obligated but we don’t really know what would be appreciated. If you are fortunate, as I am, consider helping your community. It may result in fewer gifts under the tree but may make us appreciate each one a little more and focus on the things that matter more – spending time and taking care of each other. This year, we are asking our friends to make a donation to their favorite charities instead of giving us a gift…but we’ll always take baked goods!
What's your favorite way to take care of your community during the holidays?

Did you see my Retweet today on Planned Parenthood Indianapolis offering gift certificates for its services? Helps a lot of folks who don't have health insurance take care of critical health needs. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/11/28/planned-parenthood-offers_n_146968.html
Posted by: Francine McKenna | November 28, 2008 at 11:31 AM
Francine - I had not seen that - it's a great addition to the list!
Posted by: Rachel Happe | November 28, 2008 at 11:35 AM
If you needed a better reason to stop giving stuff that we don't need: watch http://www.storyofstuff.com
Posted by: Rachel Happe | November 28, 2008 at 11:56 AM
I agree that adults swapping trivial gifts is a little soul destroying.
Some suggestions: do something for someone and they do something for you - a task you love and they hate. Personally I am always happy to get a bottle of home made jam. Setting up Skype or Facebook for an older person so they can communicate more readily with their grandchildren?
Do a community project together. This may be a big one before 2009 is out. This year helping out in soup kitchen seems to be in. Next year having a block party so a soup kitchen is not/less needed or so people who can't travel home have somewhere to celebrate might be better.
Giving a mobile/cell phone to an older person and ringing their relatives to get all the numbers so they are up and going. Teach them to text.
Giving a 'job' to youngsters in the neighbourhood to give them some spare cash. Get the youngster to teach the older person?
Organizing a Xmas party for the relatives of people working at factories, firestations, etc. to say thankyou.
Posted by: Jo | November 29, 2008 at 08:51 AM
I love the giving too. I don't mind the getting when it's family or very close friends, but sometimes you're faced with incredible generosity that you're not sure you'll be able to repay--that's a real challenge.
When I left my last job at Topaz, I gave everybody a few nicely wrapped gifts, and a card. The gifts turned out to be silly things that, for the most part, were either a) lying around my office; b) claimed specifically by that person; or c) cost me under $5.
I left them on people's chairs the evening I left for the last time--so nobody would feel any obligation to give back. While I did spend time figuring the right gift for each person, most of the time went into the wrapping and the cards.
I don't think you're alone this season in wondering if money could be better spent on more practical and meaningful things, though!
Posted by: Todd Van Hoosear | November 29, 2008 at 08:33 PM
Jo & Todd - Great suggestions! Thanks for stopping by and sharing.
Over the weekend I also discovered a great additional resource to help find local charities called Network for Good - http://www.networkforgood.org - brought to us by the same find folks who run http://www.volunteermatch.org
Happy Giving!
Posted by: Rachel Happe | December 01, 2008 at 08:47 AM